How to Succeed at #Fail

Why failing frequently and openly in online campaigns will lead to greater social impact

Michael Silberman is a senior online campaigns strategist. He is a partner and co-founder of EchoDitto, a leading digital strategy and technology team supporting the social change sector. More via @silbatron

 

 

Jonathan Warnow works to harness new media and social technology to catalyze large-scale change. He is a co-founder of 350.org, an innovative global climate campaign that has used a model of open-source activism to coordinate 10,000 offline events in 181 countries.


 

Ever get a sinking feeling after you’ve launched a great email, set up a great online action, built a thriving online community or implemented a perfect graphic? You know the one: a nagging sense that you’ve failed to truly move the needle forward on your issue--that maybe you’re just re-arranging the deck chairs?

 

Or maybe you were involved in an online effort that obviously fell flat--and then find yourself going through the same motions with the same failed tactics weeks later?

 

Failures happen all the time in our sector, but we’re all pretty poor at admitting it. After all, why should we go out of our way to make ourselves feel bad, or put our job or professional reputation on the line?  

 

The instinct to avoid dwelling on failure is natural, but for online organizers and campaigners this tends to take our natural human aversion to failure to some extreme levels. Many of us feel obligated to evangelize the benefits of “new media” and “social technologies.” After all, we’re working to convince cautiously optimistic co-workers and skeptical boards of directors that these digital bells and whistles are more than hype, and it’s often a safe bet that we’re making that sales job even harder if we dwell on mistakes or our (lack of) efficacy.

 

So we carry on, shamelessly promoting the power of social technology and parroting the buzzwords that reinforce our job security. A quick scan of our sectors’ professional listservs would indicate that we’re all innovating and cranking out an endless parade of brilliant campaigns, websites and gizmos; rarely is there any talk about the real-world social impact that these whiz-bang campaigns had toward fulfilling their organization’s larger external mission.

 

Instead of zooming out to assess big-picture impacts, we focus on internal micro-metrics. It’s easy to see why: online campaigners have near-instant access to statistics that claim to reveal, with oddly satisfying precision, just how well we’re doing. So we elevate the importance of empirical Metrics Of Success: click-through rates, conversion percentages, retweets and the like. And we iterate based on those metrics, testing different subject lines, page layouts and pithy declarations. But too often, critical questions are left unasked.

 

Do you know how those 346 Facebook “likes” helped you save lives today? Or can you explain how those 49 re-tweets will help change the committee chair’s position?

 

We almost take it on faith that upping these numbers is an end unto itself.

 

Make no mistake: more of our campaigns and organizations could benefit from a strong focus on analytics. Outfits like Obama for America’s New Media Team and MoveOn.org have harnessed insights provided by web analytics to serve their missions more effectively, and they have tangible victories to prove it (Obama’s analytics guru is working to make some basic A/B tests more accessible through a new service, optimizely.com).

 

But our challenge is not simply to create a culture of rigorous statistical analysis--we need a culture that thinks critically about real-world impact and is willing to see mistakes for what they are: valuable tools for learning.  

 

As Steve Andersen outlines so convincingly, we’d do well to think of ourselves as Scientists for Change. Or as Shayna Englin says, we must stay focused on Connecting Advocacy to Change. We’re beginning to see a community-wide call to support one another in staying focused on what matters, and the various missions or movements that brought many of us into this work in the first place. (The alternative is grim: a culture of distraction, where digital trees obscure the real-world forest, and we’re likely to waste the money, energy and time of our staff and our supporters).

 

Fortunately, times are changing and our space is maturing. Our exuberance over technology is increasingly giving way to constructive, critical evaluations of how technology is helping us achieve our broader goals and achieve positive social impact. There have been a slew of recent critiques examining the limits of the most commonly used online campaigning tools: the e-petition and the letter “to” Congress. Our friends at MobileActive just organized a “FailFaire” to examine how we can more effectively use technology to improve the lives of poor people--by examining the shortcomings of efforts tried to date.  

 

We applaud this trend--and seek to accelerate it. Both of us were part of a team that invested countless hours in planning and designing a networked online organizing platform for the climate movement. The program, and its custom or “white label” social networking platform, never achieved its full potential and was ultimately shut down. We applaud the 1Sky campaign in releasing a case study of this project and see great value in sharing lessons from our failures.

 

The social technology space moves quickly, and it’s hard to find the time to face the moments when we (and the technology we rely upon) have come up short. But it’s crucial. The goals we’re all working toward are too important for us to avoid these conversations any longer. And while we might not have the metrics to back it up, we’re quite sure that we’ll fail to succeed if we don’t collectively succeed at failing.

 

So what can technologists on the front lines learn from your own, and others’ failures? A few questions, ideas and resources to consider:

  • Shared Ownership: Who else within your organization or team assumes responsibility for success or failures online--just you, or is ‘internet’ ownership distributed across the organization? Movement-leading organizations tend to have staff developing, considering or implementing digital strategies at all levels of the organization and, as a result, are less likely to abdicate responsibility to a junior staffer.
  • Debrief: Make project debriefs part of your culture, and develop a system for retaining lessons and wisdom from campaign successes--and failures. Or start a  ‘Failure Fridays’ brownbag lunch event (h/t Joe Solomon): On the last Friday of the month, invite your team to huddle and talk about what didn’t work. Give your failures the respect they deserve and seed new solutions to experiment with and grow in the month ahead.
  • Clear Theory of Change, Impact Statement: Can you construct a pithy and plausible argument for your campaign that stands up to critical scrutiny and thinking? Doing so will help steer you clear of some of the more obvious errors that stand in the way of supporter engagement and real-world impact.
    • If you do X, it will help our organization/movement do Y which will help us accomplish Z mission.
  • Peer Review: Create your own peer review system--who are the trusted colleagues that can road-test an idea with you? Build your inner circle--your kitchen cabinet--of friends and colleagues who can appreciate the need for quick and honest feedback and never will make you feel “judged.”
    • Resource: We don’t know of one. Let’s build it--at WOC 2010, in the comments here, at a local Net Tuesday or through a post of your own.

Cross posted at Huffington Post

Comments

Add Your Comment
Boeh's picture

Harga Mobil Baru Bandung

Daihatsu Motor Co. Ltd. adalah perusahaan mobil tertua di Jepang, dan terkenal dengan produk mobil - mobilnya yang berukuran kecil atau kompak. kantor pusat Daihatsu berada di Ikeda, Prefektur Osaka. Dealer Mobil Daihatsu Bandung merupakan sarana informasi Spesifikasi, Kredit dan Harga Daihatsu Bandung seperti Xenia, Sirion, Luxio, Terios, Grand Max dan Ayla.
Mazda Motor Corporation merupakan perusahaan otomotif di Jepang. Perusahaan ini berdiri pada tahun 1920 dan bermarkas di Fuchu, Distrik Aki, Hiroshima. Kredit harga Mobil Mazda Bandung memberikan informasi tentang Harga Mobil Mazda CX5 Bandung, Spesifikasi, dan Fitur utuk semua kendaran mazda seperti Mazda 2 Hatchback, Mazda 6, Mazda 8, Biante, CX 9, MX 5, VX 1, BT 50, dan BT 50 Pro.
Kia Motors didirikan pada tahun 1944 di Seoul Korea Selatan. KIA yang merupakan singkatan dari Korean International Automotive Dealer Kredit Mobil Kia Bandung masuk ke Indonesia pada tahun 1999 dengan Agen Tunggal Pemegang Merk, PT Kia Mobil Indonesia. Dealer Penjualan Kredit Kia Bandung, merupakan pusat informasi Kia, Picanto, Rio, Carens, Sorento, Optima, Travello, Pregio, dan Big Up.
Ford Motor Company merupakan sebuah produsen mobil yang berasal dari Amerika Serikat yang didirikan oleh Henry Ford di Dearborn, Ford didirikan pada tanggal 16 Juni 1903. Di Indonesia khususnya Jawa Barat dan Bandung kami Dealer mobil Ford Bandung, memberikan informasi Spesifikasi, Kredit Dan Harga mobil Ford Bandung. seperti Mobil Ford Fiesta Bandung, Focus, Everest, Ranger, Ecosport.
Mitsubishi Motors Corporation didirikan oleh Yataro Iwasaki pada 1970 Markas Mitsubhisi berada di Tokyo. Dealer Harga Mitsubishi Bandung memberikan informasi tentang Spesifikasi, Harga dan Kredit Mobil Mitsubishi Bandung yang beredar di pasar Indonesia diantaranya adalah Pajero Sport, Mitsubishi Outlander, Mirage, Strada Triton Delica, Colt T120SS, Colt L300, Colt Diesel, Fuso.
Kredit Mobil Honda Bandung adalah Update Paket Kredit tebaru dari Kredit mobil Honda Bandung di indonesia khususnya Jawa Barat. Data Kredit mobil Honda selalu kami Update setiap ada perubahan Total DP, Angsuran / Cicilan ataupun Bunga Bank. Untuk perhitungan Kredit dengan Total DP, cicilan, tenor/jangka waktu kredit yang diinginkan, silahkan Kunjungi kami di : Dealer Mobil Bandung
Honda Mobilio meskipun pemain baru di kelas Low MPV namun siap bersaing dengan para kompetitornya. Honda Mobilio Bandung dengan berbagai fitur, fasilitas, dan teknologi, yang canggih, harga yang terjangkau, tapi tetap memberikan kenyamanan dan keamanan lebih bagi penggunanya.
Toyota Bandung adalah pusat informasi mengenai Kendaraan Toyota di Bandung, Jawa Barat. Informasi harga mobil baru Toyota, spesifikasi, fitur, dan Kredit Toyota Bandung. Seperti Mobil Toyota Avanza, Etios, Kijang innova, Yaris, Rush, Corolla Altis, Vios, Alphard, Camry, FT 86, Prius, Previa, Hilux, Dyna, Nav1, Hi Ace, Toyota Fortuner Bandung, dan juga lcgc yaitu Mobil Toyota Agya.
Suzuki Ertiga Untuk kelas mobil Low MPV (Low Multi Purpose Machine), Suzuki Ertiga Bandung Merupakan jagoannya dari Suzuki. Dengan mengusung beberapa teknologi baru Suzuki Ertiga ini sangat nyaman untuk dikendarai juga membuat perjalanan anda bersama keluarga menjadi lebih menyenangkan. Untuk Info lebih lengkap kunjungi kami di : Dealer Mobil Suzuki Bandung
Nissan Motor Company Ltd adalah sebuah produsen otomotif yang berasal dari Jepang. Dulunya Nissan dipasarkan dengan merek Datsun sampai pada tahun 1983. Kantor pusatnya terletak di wilayah Ginza dari Chūō-ku, Tokyo. Dealer Mobil Nissan Bandung memberikan Informasi Kredit Harga Nissan Bandung seperti Nissan Grand Livina, March, Juke, Evalia, Livina X gear, Nissan X Trail, Serena, Teana, Navara, Elgrand, dan Murano.
Dealer Penjualan Cash Kredit Chevrolet Bandung Info Harga Promo Diskon Chevrolet Spin, Aveo, Captiva, Orlando, Colorado, Trailblazer. Chevrolet Captiva yang memiliki beberapa perubahan dengan teknologi dan desain baru untuk menjaga ketangguhan dalam berkendara.Chevrolet Spin Activ yang merupakan varian tertinggi dari keluarga Spin ini, tampilannya dibuat lebih tangguh dan keren layaknya sebuah SUV. Tampilan sporty dan gagah merupakan perwujudan dari gaya hidup generasi muda dan keluarga muda yang mencari cerminan sebuah SUV pada mobil MPV. Info Kredit Chevrolet Spin Captiva Orlando Bandung

ace maxs's picture

barang sampai baru bayar

ACE MAXS merupakan produk unggulan dari PT. H2O karena mengandung XANTHONE yang merupakan sebuah kandungan antioksidan super yang terdapat dalam kulit dan daging buah manggis, si ratu eksotik yang terkenal dengan sebutan ratu segala buah (queen of fruits). Buah yang jujur begitulah sebutan lain dari manggis, dan H2O menghadirkan untuk Anda dalam kombinasi brilian dengan ekstrak daun sirsak yang sangat terkenal dengan khasiatnya mengusir kanker dan berbagai penyakit lainnya.harg obat ace maxs
obat kista
obat keputihan
obat jantung koroner
obat kuat
obat diabetes
obat stroke herbal
obat paru paru herbal
pengobatan kanker payudara

gozagates's picture

Harga kredit mobil Murah Bandung

Produk Mobil Kia yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Rio, Carens, Sportage, Sorento, Optima, Travello, Pregio, dan Big up. Dealer dan Kredit Kia Bandung memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Kia . info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Harga Mobil Kia Bandung

Produk Mobil Mazda yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Mazda 6, Mazda 8, Biante, CX 5, CX 9, MX 5, VX 1, BT 50, dan BT 50 Pro. Kredit di Dealer Mazda Bandung memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Kia . info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Harga Kredit Mobil Mazda Bandung

Produk Nissan yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Livina, March, Juke, Evalia, XTrail, Serena, Teana, Nevara, Elgrand, dan Murano. Harga dan Kredit Nissan Bandung memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Nissan. info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Dealer Harga Mobil Nissan Bandung

Produk Ford yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Fiesta, Ecosport, Focus, Everest, dan Ranger. harga Kredit Ford Bandung memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Ford. info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Dealer harga Mobil Ford Bandung

Produk Toyota yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Avanza, Agya, Etios Valco, Kijang Innova, Yaris, Rush, Vios, Corolla Altis, Fortuner, Camry, Hilux, dan yang baru Nav1 dan Hi Ace. Kredit mobil Toyota Bandung memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Toyota. info lengkap kunjungi kami

Ada deh's picture

dfada

Waktunya download software full version dan internetan gratis nih mas bro

Rapi Amat's picture

keuangan masalah penting

Misalnya, jika anggaran Anda kecil, Anda dapat memilih untuk mengubah hanya item penting beberapa di dapur Anda. Hal ini tidak akan melibatkan menghapus pintu, jendela, atau apa pun yang membutuhkan air mata-down utama. Anda hanya dapat mengubah lampu untuk memberikan ruang dapur Anda secara keseluruhan baru
Review Agen Pokr
Rajamerahcom Situs Judi Pokr Online Terbaik Terpercaya
PokrBuayacom Agen Judi Pokr Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya
Judi Domino 99 Online ItuDomino
ItuCasnonet Agen Judi Togel Online dan Casno Online Indonesia
Judi Bola Online ItuBolanet
IniPokrnet Judi Domino 99 Online Terpercaya Indonesia
ItuPokrnet Agen Judi Domino 99 Online
Indowinpokrnet Judi Domino 99 Online Indonesia
Pokr757net Agen Judi Domino 99 Online

Powered by Jasa SEO - Jasa Review

Anonymous's picture

whiteness and femininity

whiteness and femininity issue information please visit ..
Crystal X Asli PT. Natural Nusantara Yogyakarta
jual crystal x asli nasa jogja

Eczema Free Forever Reviews's picture

Add Your Comment | Web of Change

I drop a comment when I appreciate a article on a website or if
I have something to valuable to contribute to the conversation. Usually it's
caused by the sincerness displayed in the post I read.
And on this article How to Succeed at #Fail | Web of Change.
I was excited enough to leave a thought ;
) I do have a couple of questions for you if it's okay. Could it be only me or do
a few of the comments appear like they are coming from brain dead
people? :-P And, if you are posting on other places, I'd like to follow you.
Would you list the complete urls of your social pages like your
Facebook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

canopy kain's picture

pembuatan canopy kain awning jakarta

Kami merupakan Produsen canopy kain awning jakarta dengan mutu dan kualitas terjamin dan bergaransi:
canopy kain
awning gulung
awning minimalis

http://www.w3ightl055.com's picture

Add Your Comment | Web of Change

I think the admin of this website is actually
working hard in support of his web site, for the reason that here every data is quality
based stuff.

Boeh's picture

dealer mobil murah

Produk Mobil chevrolet yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari :Mobil Chevrolet Spin, Aveo, Captiva, Orlando, Colorado,

Trailblazer. Mobil Murah Chevrolet memberi informasi lengkap tentang

Harga, spesifikasi, dan fitur, semua kendaraan Honda. info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Mobil Murah Chevrolet

Produk Mobil Honda yang beredar di Indonesia terdiri dari : Jazz, Civic, City, Accord, Mobilio, Brio Satya, CR-V, CR-Z, dan

Odyssey.Harga Mobil HondaHarga Mobil

HondaHarga Mobil suzuki memberi informasi lengkap tentang Harga, spesifikasi,

dan fitur, semua kendaraan Honda. info lengkap kunjungi kami di : Harga Mobil

suzuki Harga Mobil Suzuki

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Platinum Sponsors




Change.com Salesforce Foundation Hollyhock

Gold Sponsors

Salsa Labs

Silver Sponsors

Care2 Wire Media Blue State Digital Agentic Firefly Partners Beaconfire

Bronze Sponsors

Advomatic Crowdtangle JacksonRiver Engaging Networks Sea Change Strategies ActionSprout Fission Strategy Organizer

supporting sponsors

Gott Advertising Center for Community Change