Session Notes: Progressive online media - Let's talk

This session was organized talk-show style, with the ever-charismatic host Philip Smith, from Community Bandwidth. Philip welcomed the studio audience (it was being podcast) and introduced the panel: Michelle Hoar, from BC's political online publication, The Tyee; Dean Ericksen, from the environmental online daily, Grist; and Audrey Watson, from Yes!, a quarterly magazine dedicated to social justice issues.

Philip lobbed a number of broad questions, which panelists caught with aplomb, offering interesting commentary from their particular perspectives. Dean kept things lively by peppering the conversation with cheeky one-liners.

You can listen here:

Key questions the panel addressed were:

1. The importance and difficulty of starting up an online publication (or online counterpart to print publication) and pushing the independent media movement. How do we measure our success?

2. How can media activists ensure the sustainability of online media e.g. how can it be financially viable?

3. What is the future direction of citizen journalism?

Dean noted how Grist’s mission is not to preach to the choir, but rather to get the information out to the masses to enable people to make small changes in their lives that have big implications on a planetary scale. Grist’s strategy to earn and keep readers combines targeted surveys, focus groups, and giving away cool stuff, like eco-tour and hybrid cars.

On a short fiscal leash – like most indie publications, print or digital – The Tyee puts most of its resources into content creation to ensure high quality journalism. But Michelle acknowledged that this approach was of limited benefit and that the Tyee needs to shift ifs focus to growing the organization to be more sustainable, more strategic, and more creative.

The discussion turned to a major and well-known disadvantage of online publications, and the web in general: the extreme difficulty of turning a profit. While on the one hand, virtual publications have significant cost savings over their print counterparts (e.g. paper/printing) they are not able to operate in under the old publishing paradigm of selling ads to cover the majority of operating costs, and even make money(!) Revenue streams varied for the different publications, including donors, government, subscribers and fundraising. Panelists were hopeful that online advertising would become increasingly a more viable option.

This discussion of advertising segued into an interesting and somewhat contentious debate around the relationship between advertising and editorial. Some in the room advocated passionately for the strict separation between the two; any compromise on this would lead to advertiser meddling, a slippery, sleazy slope indeed. Others thought that this line could be crossed with no consequence. In fact, the line was called antiquated, outmoded and out of place in our tech savvy New World. Matchmaking between “tastemakers” and lifestyle purveyors was hailed as the coolest thing since Flickr. Still others suggested a completely different model based on taxation, which required policy change and legislation (and a fuck of an amount of political will). But if Canada can do it with television broadcasting, then why not for publications – be they print or virtual? There’s more than one way to skin a cat.

This debate led to musings around an obvious question: Will people ever pay for content online? Because of the context in which the Internet was developed (informally with that hacker ethic of collaboration, sharing, volunteerism, etc.) and because of the way the majority of Internet users were introduced to the medium (as an essentially free tool/service). Some said yes, people would pay for Internet content that is important to them, especially in times of need (or pain, as one traumatized American participant put it). Others pointed out that the history of the medium is so short, it’s not appropriate to draw confident conclusions about what is/is not possible for the Internet.

It was not all sobering news for the online news world. One significant advantage of virtual publications was highlighted: the ability to archive old content to make it available (arguably) in perpetuity. Not only does this provide an easily accessed historical record, it provides more opportunities for new readers to stumble across the publication through searches. And here the importance of tagging was also noted.


Add Your Comment
ahli kunci surabaya's picture

Ahli Kunci di Surabaya

Ahli Kunci di Surabaya Membuka Layanan domestik dan komersial di Surabaya dan Sekitarnya,Kami membuka layanan yang aman dan Juga Profesional ahli kunci surabaya tukang kunci surabaya pakar kunci surabaya

arnoldoasif's picture

I am very happy

I am very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation t hat's at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best posting. Agen Bola

garinludlow's picture

Thanks so much with this

Thanks so much with this fantastic new web site. I’m very fired up to show it to anyone. It makes me so satisfied your vast understanding and wisdom have a new channel for trying into the world. Ibcbet

dominobet's picture

game online

sungguh luar biasa artikel ini saya rasa,semoga saja anda semakin meningkatnya amazing

bandar capsa

riegel permalux cottonblend's picture

Add Your Comment | Web of Change

I was recommended this blog by my cousin. I'm not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble.
You are wonderful! Thanks!


thank you very useful

thank you very useful information, please visit this website:

i like thisq's picture

peluang usaha

saat ini informasi mengenai smartphone dapat anda temukan dengan mudah dengan cara klik info hp selengkapnya atau anda dapat klik informasi smartphone selengkapnya hanya disini untuk mengetahui informasi mendetail dari sebuah smartphone. membeli sebuah smartphone harus memastikan terlebih dahulu spesifikasi ponsel tersebut yakni dengan cara baca spesifikasi ponsel terbaru dan juga untuk informasi lebih banyak dapat baca spesifikasi detailnya yang berisi banyak sekali spesifikasi ponsel terbaru. saat ini harga sebuah smartphone terus berubah-ubah, dari pada bingung anda dapat klik disini sekarang juga untuk mengetahui harga smartphone terbaru, atau anda dapat klik detail selengkapnya untuk mengetahui harga ponsel terbaru saat ini. sebagai seorang yang kritis dalam memilih smartphone, anda dapat baca informasi info ponsel untuk mengetahui informasi ponsel tahun ini, atau anda juga dapat membaca read more info smartphone terbaru untuk mengetahui informasi ponsel secara lengkap. mengetahui spesifikasi ponsel dapat anda lakukan dengan cara klik info smartphone atau juga dapat membaca pada ulasan kami di baca informasi smartphone yang membahas informasi smartphone terkini. kesehatan merupakan hal yang penting, maka dari itu anda harus banyak-membaca referensi kesehatan seperti yang ada pada simak referensi kesehatan berikut ini, atau anda juga dapat membacanya secara lengkap di selengkapnya tentang kesehatan di sini untuk mengetahui lebih dalam tentang informasi kesehatan. selain ramuan alami yang menyehatkan, anda juga di tuntut untuk baca tips dan trik kesehatan yang juga dapat anda baca di selengkapnya tentang kesehatan agar kesehatan anda terus terjaga. referensi hidup sehat dapat anda temukan lebih banyak pada read more hidup sehat dan kuat atau anda juga dapat membacanya dengan cara klik sehat disini untuk mendapatkan informasi kesehatan. mencari artikel kesehatan saat ini dapat anda temukan langsung dengan cara baca kesehatan lebih detail atau anda dapat baca ulasan kesehatan selengkapnya yang mana berisi ulasan kesehatan terlengkap. informasi kesehatan merupakan hal yang wajib anda cari yakni dengan cara klik info sehat sekarang atau anda dapat langsung membaca edisi kesehatan terlengkap dengan cara klik informasi sehat hanya disini sehingga anda menemukan info kesehatan terkini.

Anonymous's picture

Considering a cooking career,

Considering a cooking career, you also wish to consider just how much you may make. You might be able to earn upwards of $40, 000 annually. This depends upon where a person work in the united kingdom, what type of education you've, and that your company is. The greater you learn about baking as well as pastry, the greater you turn out to be valuable for your employer. communicatcareers

fish oil capsules epa's picture

Add Your Comment | Web of Change

Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic however I'd
figured I'd ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or
maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My blog covers a lot
of the same topics as yours and I believe we could greatly benefit
from each other. If you are interested feel free to shoot me an email.
I look forward to hearing from you! Superb blog
by the way!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Platinum Sponsors Salesforce Foundation Hollyhock

Gold Sponsors

Salsa Labs

Silver Sponsors

Care2 Wire Media Blue State Digital Agentic Firefly Partners Beaconfire

Bronze Sponsors

Advomatic Crowdtangle JacksonRiver Engaging Networks Sea Change Strategies ActionSprout Fission Strategy Organizer

supporting sponsors

Gott Advertising Center for Community Change