We Must Be Scientists for Change

By Steve Andersen on 09/07/2010 - 12:12

Steve Andersen is Vice President of Technology and Innovation at Salesforce.com Foundation where he helps nonprofits use Salesforce.com to change the world. He believes we are at a point in time where agents of social change can get access to the same quality technology systems that large corporations can.

"We know very little, and yet it is astonishing that we know so much, and still more astonishing that so little knowledge can give us so much power." - Charles Franklin Kettering (1876-1958) Engineer, inventor, and co-founder of the Sloan-Kettering Institute

We in the social change sector are working to address the most important problems in our world today. Justice, equality, poverty, sustainability...we're not shy in putting our stake in the ground and taking on these daunting issues. I love that about this community -- the willingness to stand in the face of massive adversity, to think creatively, and try new things in the effort to bring about change. We’re innovative, we’re resourceful, and we achieve real results.

And yet as enamored as I am with the chutzpah I see in myself and my colleagues, I am unsettled. I look at my work and at what we've all achieved and I come to the unwelcome conclusion that it's not enough. Change isn’t happening fast enough. I’m not being the change agent I want to be, and the movement isn’t living up to its potential. Why aren’t we farther along our path to change? It’s clearly not from a lack of desire, creativity, hard work, and just plain smarts. Spend one day in the social change arena and you know all of these traits are present in abundance. Why, then, are we all frustrated with the speed of change?

I think part of the answer may be that although we are incredibly creative, we, as a movement, are not scientific enough in our approach. By applying scientific methods more broadly to our work, I think we can accelerate our impact and get closer to our audacious goals.

At heart I'm a scientist -- my first real job was in molecular biology and later I began my tech career at a biotech firm. I developed a deep respect for the scientific method -- how it starts with an idea, poses that idea as a testable question, and then strives to answer that question through experimentation. I am in awe of scientists who see a result and immediately ask the next question. I respect measurement, and I trust in evidence.

In publishing her findings, a scientist is making an argument for how she thinks the world works. At the same time, she publishes her methods -- the techniques and technologies she used to get her results. She shares her methods so that others might replicate her experiments and see for themselves. But even more importantly this shared knowledge can be applied to other problems she hasn’t even considered. The spread of new ideas and technology though scientific publication, this cycle of advancement, has driven the progress of science for centuries.

We must be scientists for change. I think being more scientific is the only way we can make good on the amazing opportunities in front of us. I see four main qualities that we need to foster in our movement to become more effective:

A willingness to experiment with bold ideas and strategies in testable ways
Excellence in the creative application of technology in service of those experiments
Meticulous interpretation and sharing of results
Imaginative posing of the logical next question and returning to step 1 as quickly as possible

Testing Bold Ideas

When we come up with a new thought, “I wonder if college students would be more active if they received messages about the issue from their friends,” we should reframe it as a hypothesis. Reframed: “College students will lobby decision makers at a higher rate if they are engaged by their trusted circle in a convenient way.” This is a better way of posing the question, as it can be proven true or false. We’ve removed the ambiguity, and we can design our work to speak to the question.

We can’t test this hypothesis by blasting personalized SMSs to 12,000 students. If we did and we got a low response, what have we learned? There are too many unknowns--maybe they didn’t like getting messages from friends, maybe they were upset by the $0.10 we just added to their phone bill, maybe they were all at the big football game.

Better design can give us more information. We could send SMSs from trusted friends to one group of 3,000 students. Another set could receive a generic action alert via SMS. A third group could receive an email from a trusted friend. The final 3,000 could get an email from our organization. We need to start thinking about controlling our experiments -- isolating the factors we want to test. In the four-part design outlined above, we’re trying to test two main factors -- the method of communication and the messenger. By carefully designing our experiments to isolate what we’re testing, we are guaranteed to learn something from it. In this case we may learn that message and messenger don’t make a lick of difference, but even that would be a valuable lesson.

Excellence in Technical Execution

Our experiments require a certain amount of skill with modern technology, often ones with which we’re not yet comfortable. If designed correctly, our experiments will generate data that will be nearly as important as the outcome of the effort itself. We must become excellent at trying new things with technology and also at building stable systems to support analysis of our data.

Many groups struggle with sending a single mass email and would look at the experiment above and have no idea where to begin making it happen. That needs to change. We need to embrace the use of technology instead of fearing it. We must invest in technical competency within our organizations and partner with proven implementers who can help us with our experiments. Our leaders should be in the vanguard of this effort, evangelizing the importance of technology in service of mission, be visible, competent users of technology, and invest appropriately in systems for their organizations.

Meticulous Measurement and Sharing

The data we generate will hold valuable truths, but only if we build the competency for mining it. Designing our work as testable experiments will cause us to change the way we analyze our efforts. We need more statisticians in our movement, and we’ll seek them out as our experimental results start rolling in.

If we learn from our analysis that college students are 55% more likely to respond to a personal SMS from a trusted friend than to an email, we need to tell that story, and not just in the halls of the next conference we attend. We should develop structures and systems for sharing our experimental design and the results. Our goal should be that others can replicate our work and push it in new directions. This is the best way we can invest in our movement as a whole--by contributing to our shared knowledge, “competitive advantage” be damned.

Relentless, Iterative Experimentation

In our experiment, we learned that students are much more responsive to personal SMSs than to our old way of communicating. We clearly need to start sending text messages in our daily work! But we can’t be satisfied with that single finding. What is our next experiment? What thoughts does this finding spur? We can’t hesitate to integrate what we’ve learned and pose a succeeding hypothesis, thus building our knowledge base.

If we can excel at these four traits -- testing bold ideas, excelling with technology, measuring and sharing, and relentless iteration -- we can accelerate our progress significantly. Of course it's not easy. Being rigorous and scientific in our environment is incredibly challenging. It's risky, requires specialized skills, is more expensive in the short-term, and can produce experimental results that can prove inconvenient at times for us and our organizations.

But we don’t have the luxury of playing it safe. We need to push forward and ask deep questions of ourselves. This kind of searching is going on in many places in our movement, but most notably in the global development sector. Thinkers like William Easterly, Esther Duflo, and David Roodman are laying down the gauntlet and demanding that we stop giving blindly and start running testable experiments. They are pointing out that it is actually possible to know the impact of our efforts, as long as our efforts are thoughtfully designed and meticulously analyzed.

Let’s lead by creating new ways of working for change -- ways to which we will be wedded only as long as they prove to be effective. Let’s treat our movement as a body of knowledge that we all can rely on, contribute to, and debunk parts of as appropriate. Let’s challenge each other and systematically share, all with the aim of building our movement's understanding of how to best bring about change.

Achieving massive impact isn't easy, we all know that. And there is no charted path. We are doing amazing, creative, impactful work. And we have learned so much in the process. Charles Kettering, whose quote opened this post, also said:

"Every honest researcher I know admits he's just a professional amateur. He's doing whatever he's doing for the first time. That makes him an amateur. He has sense enough to know that he's going to have a lot of trouble, so that makes him a professional."

We're attempting to tackle massive, unsolved problems, often with little more than good ideas and an abiding desire to help. We’re inventing strategies and tactics in the moment, as amateurs -- it’s exciting and challenging work. Thinking about our work scientifically can help us be brilliant professionals as well, driving us more quickly and systematically to the impact for which we all strive.

Related reading:
White Man’s Burden, William Easterly
TED Talk: Social Experiments to Fight Poverty, Esther Duflo
Critical Mass, Philip Ball

Tags:

Comments

Add Your Comment

Top 10... Pes 2013

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 26, 2013 - 4:56pm.

Excellent.
Pes 2013 is tops. I have created lessons and tricks Pes. Look at them.

thank you

Submitted by منتدى انوثتك (not verified) on April 22, 2013 - 10:04am.

good work thanks

منتديات توب عرب للمبدعين

Submitted by صور اطفال (not verified) on April 18, 2013 - 9:34am.

منتديات توب عرب للمبدعين احساس منتديات عامة
افضل المنتديات العربية
منتديات
صورة
صور
صور طبيعية
صور اطفال
صور رومانسية
صور مضحكة
صور حيوانات
غرائب وعجائب
صور كاريكاتير
صور مكة
صور تفحيط سيارات
صور صباح الخير
صور اسلامية
صور رسوم متحركة
صور اولاد
صور غريبة
صور انمي
فواصل لتزيين المواضيع
صور سيارات
صور حصان
صور من راس البر
صور العاب
funny sms
strange images sky
funny cartoon images
funny images
funny images of animals
funny birthday images
funny images of people
3d images
background images
love images
flower images
cartoon images
baby images
halloween images
dog images
cat images
funny images
funny images
Natural images
Natural images

Anónimo

Submitted by 3dlat (not verified) on April 13, 2013 - 8:58am.

fsdsdf

Submitted by العاب تلبيس بنات (not verified) on April 11, 2013 - 5:07pm.

العاب بنات تلبيس
العاب تلبيس بنات
العاب بنات تلبيس
العاب تلبيس بنات
العاب
العاب
العاب بنات
بنات
العاب بنات هاي
العاب بنات جديدة
العاب طبخ
العاب طبخ
موقع طبخ
طبخ
العاب سيارات
العاب سيارات
العاب فلاش
سيارات
العاب سيارات سباق
العاب اكشن
العاب تنظيف
العاب مضحكة
العاب تلبيس
العاب تلبيس
العاب اطفال
العاب سبونج بوب
العاب بن تن
العاب بن تن 10
العاب بن 10
العاب ذكاء
العاب باربي
العاب مكياج
العاب ميك اب
العاب قص الشعر
العاب قص شعر
العاب المزرعة السعيدة
لعبة المزرعة السعيدة
العاب المزرعة
العاب المزارع
العاب مزرع
العاب مصارعة
العاب مصارعة حرة
العاب المصارعة الحرة
العاب friv
العاب friv 2013
العاب ذكاء 2013
العاب طبخ 2013
العاب طبخ 2014
العاب ذكاء 2014
العاب سيارات 2013
العاب سيارات 2014
العاب فلاش 2013
العاب بنات 2013
العاب بنات 2014
العاب تلبيس 2013
العاب تلبيس 2014
العاب اكشن 2013
العاب اكشن 2015
العاب فلاش 2013
العاب فلاش 2014
العاب بنات ستايل

منتديات

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 4, 2013 - 6:00pm.

منتديات
منتديات اية
منتديات اية النسائي
منتديات ايه النسائى
منتديات ايه
مركز تحميل صور
صور بنات
صوربنات
مركز رفع الملفات
فساتين 2013
ديكورات 2013
تسريحات 2013
مكياج 2013
فساتين العروس 2013
ازياء رجالي 2013
رمزيات بلاك بيري
رسائل حب 2013
برودكاست
نكت 2013
توبيكات 2013
برامج بلاك بيري
صور مشاهير 2013
غلاف للفيس بوك
صور حب 2013
سيارات 2013
شعر 2013
ازياء اطفال
اكسسوارات
تردد القنوات
فساتين دانتيل
صور فاطمة وكريم
صور زهور
مكياج بنات
صور رومانسية
صور قلوب
صور بنات
صور حزينة
صورةاجمل امراة
صورالجماع
صور غلاف للفيس بوك
نكت 2013
توبيكات واتس اب
تسريحات شعر
صور عشاق
صور كيا ريو
خلفيات بلاك بيري
تسريحات فخمه
تسريحات 2013
ملابس للمحجبات
لفات حجاب
رمزيات نسائية
تحميل الواتس اب
صورة اجمل امراة
تسريحات ليله العمر
اغلفة حب للفيسبوك
صور احضان قوية
صور احضان وبوس
صور دومينيك حوراني
صور امال ماهر
رمزيات نسائية
دعاء صلاة الاستخارة
صور جماع
صور الجماع
صور حب
صور حب 2014
صور حب متحركة
صور بنات مغريه
اجمل بنات
صور رومانسيه
لحظات رومانسيه
صور عرسان رومانسيه
فساتين سهره طويله
فساتين زفاف
تسريحات لشعر
تنورات قصيره
تسريحات لشعر القصير
ساعات حائط
اغلفه للفيس رومانسيه
فساتين مغريه
صور قبلات عرسان
نمبر بوك
تحميل برنامج نمبر بوك
بنات الفيس بوك
صور بنات الفيس بوك
برنامج سكاى بى
تحميل برنامج سكاى بى
برنامج سكاي بي للجوال
صورعارية
صور عارية
صور جنس
صورجنس
صور بنات العراق
صور عراقيات
صورةاجمل امراة سعودية
صور بنات السعودية
صور بنات سعوديات
صورةاجمل امراة مصرية
صور بنات مصر
صور بنات مصريات
تردد قناة الجزيرة الرياضية
تردد الجزيرة الرياضية
الجزيرة الرياضية
تردد قناة روتانا سينما
تردد قناه روتانا سينما
قناة روتانا سينما
تردد قناة زي افلام
تردد زى افلام
قناة زي افلام
سورة الناس
تفسير سورة الناس
سورة الناس مكتوبة بالتشكيل
سورة الفلق
تفسير سورة الفلق
سورة الفلق مكتوبة بالتشكيل
سورة الاخلاص
تفسير سورة الاخلاص
سورة الاخلاص مكتوب بالتشكيل
سورة القدر
تفسير سورة القدر
سورة القدر مكتوبة بالتشكيل
سورة الفجر
تفسير سورة الفجر
سورة الفجر مكتوبة بالتشكيل
سورة المطففين
تفسير سورة المطففين
سورة المطففين مكتوبة بالتشكيل
سورة النبأ
تفسير سورة النبأ
سورة النبأ مكتوبة بالتشكيل
فساتين سوارية
فساتين سهرة
فساتين سهره للحوامل
فساتين الممثلات
فساتين مناسبات
اكسسوارات بنات
فساتين سهرة تركية
فساتين سهرة للمراهقات
فساتين للحوامل مودرن
فساتين سهرة حديثة
فساتين تجنن
فساتين طويله لصيف
فساتين سهره طويله
سارى هندى
كولكشن ازياء
مايوهات لبنات
فساتين حديثه

العاب بنات العاب فلاش العاب

Submitted by mmm (not verified) on April 1, 2013 - 4:17am.

العاب بنات
العاب فلاش
العاب 2013

flash games
العاب تلبيس
العاب اكشن
العاب طبخ
العاب كارتون
العاب
العاب غامبول
العاب ميك اب
العاب مكياج
العاب سيارات

العاب

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on March 31, 2013 - 12:37pm.

العاب
العاب فلاش
العاب اكشن
العاب بنات هاي هاي
العاب اطفال
العاب سيارات فقط
العاب توم و جيري
العاب ماريو
العاب سبونج بوب فقط
العاب دورا
العاب بن 10
العاب سونيك
العاب ذكاء
العاب تلوين
العاب مكياج فقط
العاب افلام الكرتون
العاب نكلودين
العاب طائرات
العاب كورة
العاب الطبخ فقط
العاب باربي
العاب تلبيس روعة
العاب رياضية
العاب دراجات النارية
العاب قص شعر فقط
العاب قتالية

Bimbingan Belajar (Bimbel)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on March 30, 2013 - 5:53am.

Bimbingan Belajar (Bimbel) Gratis di Fasilkom UI Depok Pasang Iklan di Blog Murah Keajaiban Matematika Membuat Hidup Lebih Mudah Perhiasan Batu Alam Indonesia Tempat Baca Komik Detektif Conan Bahasa Indonesia Online Cara Meningkatkan Kualitas Suara Android Samsung Galaxy Biaya Administrasi Penghulu Nikah di KUA Cara Meningkatkan Trust Rank Cara Membuat Page di Facebook Cheat Semua Game Android dengan GameCIH ROOT Sejarah Zaman Perunggu Rute Keberangkatan dan Tarif Bus DAMRI 2013 Jenis Jenis Batubara Sejarah Bangsa Romawi Kuno 50 Kampus Indonesia Paling Populer di Dunia Spesifikasi Android Samsung Galaxy S4 Cuti Bersama dan Hari Libur Nasional Tahun 2013 Tips Untuk Root Android Sejarah Zaman Besi Sejarah Zaman Batu Tempat Download Aplikasi Android Gratis Tanaman Tundra Binatang Siamang Alamat dan Telepon Cipaganti Travel Kalimantan Lambang Yahudi di Uang Kertas Indonesia Cara Memakai Jilbab Modern Compfest 2013 Sejarah Perang Dunia 1 Daftar Nomor Telepon Penting Darurat Alamat dan Nomor Telepon Baraya Travel Nomor Telepon Day Trans Travel Alamat dan Nomor Telepon Cipaganti Travel Jawa Timur Jakarta International Java Jazz Festival 2013 Polimer, Apa itu Polimer? Hasil Lengkap Liga Champions 2013 Update Daftar Cheat Codes The Sims 3 Daftar Cheat Codes The Sims 3 Tempat Download Game Android Gratis Cheat Tips Trik Drag Racing Android Mengganti Domain Blogger Dengan .com Gratis Daftar Transfer Liga Italia Serie A Januari 2013 Custom ROM Samsung Galaxy W Daftar Cheat Codes Sim City 4 Biodata Jokowi Ahok ROM Jelly Bean Terbaik SamsungGalaxy W Profil Universitas Gadjah Mada UGM Profil Institut Teknologi Bandung ITB Profil Universitas Indonesia UI Binatang Aligator Apa itu Bidikmisi Informasi SNMPTN 2013 Jalur Masuk UI 2013 Membuat Grafiti Secara Online 10 Pemain Sepakbola Termahal di Dunia Januari 2013 How to Resolve W3 Total Cache Page Cache URL Is Not Working Binatang Ajak Format Template Proposal Sponsorship Cheat Tips Trik Drag Racing Android Setting Terbaik W3 Total Cache Shared Hosting Plankton Submit Post Memasang Widget YM di Blog Membuat Textarea Auto Select Cara Membuat Tulisan Berjalan Apa Itu Binatang Platipus Nomor Telepon Alamat Hotel Jakarta Alamat dan Telepon Cipaganti Jawa Tengah Alamat Cipaganti Travel Jakarta Nomor Telepon Cipaganti Travel Jakarta Tempat Download Game PC Gratis Pemain Wonderkid PES 2013 Mudah Memindahkan Aplikasi Android ke SD Card Tanpa Root Contact Us Paper Traditional CRM vs Social CRM 20 Orang Indonesia Pertama di Twitter Master League PES 2013 Masa Depan Pemain Wonderkid Football Manager FM 2013 Atribut Kunci Posisi Pemain FM 2013 Spesifikasi Komputer PES 2012 Pemain Muda Bagus Master League PES 2012 Master League PES 2012 Editor Lomba Fotografi Grafkom 2012 Atribut Tersembunyi FM 2013 Spesifikasi Minimal PES 2013 Mengapa Masyarakat Dukung KPK Sitemap Nasa Membenarkan Matahari Terbit Dari Barat Computer Festival Compfest 2012 Download Kunci Jawaban SNMPTN SIMAK UI 2012 Sound Alarm Notification Ringtone Untuk Android Admin Akun Poconggg Sebenarnya Cara Download Temple Run Untuk Android Ice Cream Sandwich ICS untuk Samsung Galaxy Cara Download Instagram untuk Android Instagram untuk HP Android Lumia Windows Phone Developer Day Mulai Membuat Wordpress Memasang Favicon di Wordpress Blog Dofollow Baru Film Barat Berhenti Beredar di Indonesia Ubertwitter Dibanned oleh Twitter About Compfest 2011 Tips Trik Bermain Poker Facebook Kompetisi Blog Compfest 2011 Jayeslee Amazing Voice Bruno Mars Just The Way You Are Gombal Tapi Fail Rektor UI Berpotensi Diturunkan Add My Google Plus Jadwal Pertandingan Sepakbola SEA Games 2011 Video Kecelakaan Simoncelli Blog Baru Semangat Baru Pemenang Kompetisi Blog Compfest 2011 Akun Lama Blogger.com Akan Ditutup Juni SMS Gratis Guestbook Video Teaser Compfest 2011 Cara Menghemat Bensin Kendaraan Mobil DSKON.COM Layanan Deal Aggregator Website Group Buying 12 Nama Wasit Piala Eropa 2012 Tanda Gejala Asam Urat Kata Bijak Tentang Waktu Badak Apa Itu Alergi Drakula Vampir Akun Twitter Menarik Wajib Difollow Topologi Jaringan Mesh Topologi Jaringan Ring Cincin Topologi Jaringan Bintang Star Topologi Jaringan Topologi Jaringan Bus Cheat Angry Birds 2012 Jalur Masuk UI 2012 2013 Soal SIMAK UI 2009 2010 2011 Stand Up Comedy Permainan Linguistik Serial Number PES 2012 Cara Menampilkan Emoticon Meme di Facebook Nomor Telepon Cipaganti Travel Bandung Tentang Travel Cipaganti Group Misteri Tugu Patung Pancoran Data Klaim Negara Malaysia Atas Budaya Indonesia Daftar Pemenang New7wonders Biografi Tentang Presiden Soekarno Inspirasi Iklan Paling Menyedihkan Thailand 10 Dampak Mengerikan Internet Status Twitter Lucu Terwati Mengukur Berat Loading Blog Akurat Tes Mengetahui Kecanduan Rokok Bahaya Merokok pada Wanita Lebih Besar dari Pria Tips Trik Menghadapi SIMAK UI 2011 Mengukur Jangkauan Tweet Twitter 7 Cara Tips Menghilangkan Jerawat Secara Alami Daftar Plat Nomor Kendaraan Pejabat Indonesia Kumpulan Goal Lengkap Lionel Messi 2011 Goal Tercepat Sepanjang Sejarah Sepakbola Tips Trik Mencegah Penyakit Ginjal Cara Mengetahui Jenis Kelamin Komputer Blog Jutaan Pengunjung per Hari Alasan Kenapa Friendster Dihapus Ringkasan Cerita Harry Potter 7 10 Mobil Tercepat di Dunia Tahun 2011 Tips Cepat Mendapat Kerja Setelah Kuliah Jenis Batu Alam di Indonesia Cara Membuat Blogroll di Blog Tips Sehat Duduk di Depan Komputer Tips Trik Aman Berkendara Malam Hari Tips Trik Webmaster Google Links Jenis Jenis Logam Add On Firefox Mempercepat Download Gulma Emoticon Rahasia Plurk Tersembunyi Lengkap SEO Memasang Meta Tag di Blog Hati-hati Dengan Facebook dalam Mencari Kerja Alasan Mengapa Cinema3satu Dihapus Spesifikasi Komputer untuk iTunes Cara Mengetahui Siapa yang Unfollow Twitter Cara Membuat Paragraf Persuasif Alexa Review: Apa Itu Alexa? 10 Gempa Paling Mematikan Blue Screen of Death di Tempat Umum Belajar Mengetik Cepat Wonderkid Football Manager FM 2011 Review Plant vs Zombie BEM UI 2011 Together in Excellence Daftar Harga Kamera Digital Tips and Tricks Ahmad Jakfar Tips Trik Cheat Organisasi Manajemen Online Blog Livean Blog Lyrics

العاب

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on March 29, 2013 - 9:16am.

Post new comment

Your name:

E-mail:

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Homepage:

Subject:

Comment: *

Allowed HTML tags:
Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Web of Change Highlights

Testimonials

“Web of Change isn’t a ‘wham bam here’s my business card’ conference. I made sincere personal and professional connections with people that have lasted. Five days on Cortes Island offered me the time to learn, laugh, and understand my work and my larger place in the progressive community.”