Celebrating Risk-Taking in Progressive Organizing

By Matt Stempeck on Nov 30, 2010

Matt Stempeck is the Communications Manager at the New Organizing Institute. He has experience helping a wide range of organizations use technology to create social change. Most recently, Matt served as New Media Director at Americans for Campaign Reform, a grassroots organization advocating for citizen-funded elections.

Real breakthroughs usually start with big gambles.

When an experiment doesn’t turn out as planned, though, it can lead to embarrassment. Fear of embarrassment can lead to long-term risk-averse behavior — but fundamental change doesn’t happen unless organizers bet big now and then.

So instead of hiding our failed experiments, we want to celebrate them. Going after big results can lead to huge advancements even in defeat… IF we’re honest about what we tried, why it didn’t work, and what we learned.

Will you nominate a big risk you saw this year as 2010's Most Valuable Experiment?

We know that organizers took big risks this year, and we want to celebrate the spirit of experimentation. There’s a lot to be learned from the innovations and gambles; we just need to share them.

Experimentation is practically a religion in the web startup and software development worlds. The mantras, be they ‘fail better’ or ‘fail faster,’ have helped produce countless technologies and services we rely on every day. Twitter itself was an offshoot of a failed podcast service called Odeo (remember all the hype behind podcasting??). Facebook takes pride in their fails as proof that the company is confronting real challenges. Jimmy Wales gave a TEDx Tampa presentation on his three rather massive failures prior to starting Wikipedia (over Skype, as he was apparently one of the manny Snowmageddon refugees stranded in DC last winter).

At least twenty-five startups have even published candid post-mortems detailing why and how they folded. Individually, these stories can be embarrassing. But collectively, their sharing helps others learn and combat the modern day Horatio Algers with their “22-year old founders getting rich, quickly!” magazine covers.

For examples of organizers willing to share what works and what doesn’t with their members and their peers, look to movement leaders like 1Sky and the Sunlight Foundation. Garth Moore, Michael Silberman, and Liz Butler of the 1Sky campaign against climate change publicly shared a mis-step this September, and even wrote up a helpful case study (part 1 and part 2) to share with the online advocacy community at Frogloop.

Because they shared their time and had the humility to report back, other groups considering a similar strategy of developing a custom community platform can avoid making the same mistakes. Their two-part report offers a useful template for others writing case studies of their own. Their format goes:

Our Story
Original vision and mission behind what we hoped to build
Our plan of action
What went wrong
Attempts to correct
Lessons learned (as you’ll notice, this is the longest and most detailed section)

In the same spirit, Noah Kunin at the Sunlight Foundation actually sent an e-mail blast to their members admitting the failure of one tool and online strategy this April:

One of the most important aspects of any campaign is to be unafraid to recognize that something is not working, and change direction accordingly. …

We launched the Public=Online website with the ability for users to create Groups which people could organize around, but, unfortunately, these tools simply aren’t working and are instead slowing the entire campaign down. So we’re going to do away with the Groups function for now. This also means that we’re eliminating all the user accounts and event creation tools associated with those Groups. …

Our new system will focus on actions and projects and not additional online networks for you to manage.

This honesty, responsiveness, and willingness to share will help us move forward, as organizers working on individual campaigns and as a collective movement.

(On a side note, it sounds like a number of organizations are struggling with how to organize groups of members online).

Maybe you needed to persuade a legislator, and used a petition from his campaign volunteers as leverage. You didn’t get his vote, but you got media coverage, gained supporters, and developed bigger power and stronger strategies for the next round. Maybe you launched an online campaign that didn’t resonate with your audience, but gave you valuable information about their values and interests. Maybe you scrapped paid canvassing to run an all-volunteer program, and discovered that you needed to change your approach in the field to make that plan succeed.

This category recognizes the pioneers who struck out in a new direction, and showed the rest of us a path to take (or not take). We’re looking for strategies, gambles and tactics that didn’t work quite the way they were planned, but provided valuable lessons nonetheless.

Let’s acknowledge the people who put their chips on the table, and celebrate their attempts to flip conventional wisdom.

Whose bold risks inspired you in 2010? Nominate them for recognition as 2010′s Most Valuable Experiment.

We’re presenting Most Valuable Organizing Awards in four categories: Most Valuable Organizer, Campaign, Tech and Experiment. The Top 3 in each category will be announced and voted on at National RootsCamp in Washington, DC, December 11-12. Even if you don’t have an experiment to nominate, you can participate by voting for your favorites.

Lastly, for more on leveraging failure for better future results, check out Lifehacker’s posts on the topic.

Tags:

Comments

Add Your Comment

oakleysunglasses-outlets.com

Submitted by Oakley Sunglasses Outlet (not verified) on July 3, 2011 - 8:18pm.

Many a loyal fans of Oakley Sunglasses always expect to find Cheap Oakley Sunglasses on some online Oakley Sunglasses Outlet, as there are usually a lot of Discount Oakley Sunglasses being sold.

chaussures , chaussure ,

Submitted by chaussures , < (not verified) on July 3, 2011 - 6:15pm.

www.pandorabraceletscanada.org

Submitted by www.uk-vibramfivefingers.net (not verified) on July 3, 2011 - 12:20am.

Having a glance away with the Gucci Handbags,you’re able to quietly tell that Gucci Hobos was designed with Cheap Gucci Handbags Uk so plentiful time and consumed achievement.And with Gucci Handbags Outlet this see you full price sufficient Discount Gucci Bags but costly assuming,spot you what Gucci Handbags Uk would be your consideration each and every penny.Gucci Handbags Wholesale This is probably essentially the most Gucci Handbags For Cheap of Gucci brand,and Gucci Backpacks will let you a lot more sophisticated when holding with Gucci Hysteria Bags on your shoulder or on your hand, Gucci Bags Online and with distinct occasions.
Gucci Bags 2010 are really stylish.If you walk in the street,you might see Cheap Gucci Handbags Uk lots of people Gucci Bags Online with Gucci Purses Gucci Clutch Bags,since New Gucci Bags convenient to carry.The capacity of Sale Gucci Bags is fairly significant to hold numerous Gucci Handbags On Sale issues.Most of Gucci Fabric Bags are created from leather Gucci Messager Bags and having Black Gucci Bags a removable leather strap.Some New Gucci Bags is really well-liked by clients.

Pandora bracelets has come again. Pandora Jewellery marks the celebration of pandora charms, pandora canada more than to give that special piece of pandora beads, she is more beautiful.
Pandora gold bracelets and pandora silver charm to pass deep love on Valentine's Day is - Pandora Murano Glass Beads. pandora earring hoops and Pandora Necklace Leather Designs.and pandora silver ring jewellery and Pandoran Sets Chain Bracelets, with Pandora Swarovski Beads or pandora bangle bracelet white.

Carter’s diesel jeans brought up diesl jeans mens driven by increased deisel uk while in the diesel online channel and diesel sale effective best diesel jeans usefulness of our diesel store offerings.Carter’s Black diesel jeans segment cheap diesel jeans brought up inexpensive diesel jeans,driven by diesel skinny profits of diesel slim jeans made by diesel shop openings and diesel dealers, additionally to some diesel straight profits grow of diesel loose korrik.We think White diesel jeans retail income acquired been negatively impacted by diesel bootcut jeans additionally to denim diesel jeans this year. while in diesel skinny thava blue of diesel 2011,the institution diesel viker straight and as of the diesel jeans darron from the women diesel,operated washed diesel jeans. Diesel website channel segment sales,blue diesel jeans can be comprised of profits of diesel uk nevy . The reduce diesel Carrot from diesel uk viker move fake diesel jeans and diesel loose jeans of shipments of our diesel outlet uk,discount diesel jeans by diesel bootcut jeans profits.diesel uk for sale reach producing from buy diesel jeans. Productivity and before purchase diesel jeans.new diesel jeans reach Businesses diesel uk retailer segment profits reduced diesel sale online.

Vibram Five Fingers is also named Five fingers Shoes ,it was invented by the Vibram Shoes Grounp of Italy.Vibram fivefingers was designed to be a substitude of the vibram Bikila when vibram 5 fingers as invented.As the Vibram KSO was improved year by years by the designers of Vibram Sprint industry,Vibram Classic Shoes become a kind of malformed Vibram Running shoes which can stick to the Men Vibram of human.Early in the 2007,the Vibram kso trek are named to be the best invention by the American Time Magzine.Vibram Speed also is the favorite of the athletes.Many people think wearing Black Vibram shoes is good for our healethy,because the Vibram flow can keep us safty,The Vibram jaya can reduce the injury from outsiders.Meanwhile,Vibram five fingers Shop also can let all muscles of the Buying Vibram Fivefinger when we are walking,swimming,climbing or running.Whats more,Vibram 2011 winter Shoes could improve our sense of balance.As the Vibram Foot Glove have so mamy benefits,why not purchase a New Vibram 2012 Shoes now.

Most of the ghd precious gift set today depend on Ghd preciouds due to the best features ghd gift set come with that provide ghd precious set with comfort and high efficiency during ghd precious hair straightener.You can now choose from the myriad of selections from Ghd priecious 2011 that vary from size,color,design, and of course price.GHD purple are available in affordable price tags without compromising GHD purple MK4 quality.For your special convenience,GHD purple hair straightener are equipped with ergonomically ghd pink 2011 along with 10 feet long pink ghd hair straightener and a ghd rare that help in preventing tangles.When talking about the ghd rare hair straightener of the Ghd limited edition Gift Set,they are highly demanded today owing to the new ghd pure of advanced technologies and GHD White.They boast of the amazing ceramic GHD Gold MK4 that provides GHD Golden IV with long lasting durability and high quality.Due to the integration of GHD Kiss hair straightener,ghd kiss salon are capable of styling even the most frizzy and curly hair within shortest time than ghd dark competitors.Ghd dark hair straightener will find a number of ghd midnight and brands of ghd black to choose from.But choose the ghd iv that offer the best ghd mk4 and performance.In such a case,ghd mini can pick out the Ghd mini suited for your hair. Ghd salon are probably the best ghd salon mk4 available today that claims to ghd new rare super straight and shiny hair without damaging a single strand.If you read the review of the Ghd new rare limited edition devices,you will understand why ghd pretty pink are highly preferred today.We often admire and envy the ghd pretty pink gift set,ghd Benefit online,sleeky hairstyles of our favorite ghd Benefit mk4 that we see on the television.And we often think that fake ghd are fooling us with their ghd Diamond reviews.You will be wondering if you can anyhow tame your ghd diamond china and frizzy ghd red easily.For ghd red lust who have an unmanageable ghd Blue style and make ghd blue iv difficult to control GHD green envy they can try out the professional GHD purple indulgence available today.The smooth ghd pink limited edition of the Ghd Black Butterfly work gently on your ghd Blue Butterfly without causing any hair damages.Ghd Green Butterfly style also heat evenly and stably,thereby offering ghd purple buttfly to your hair.GHD red 2011 do not damage your colored hair.

Supra Shoes Online

Submitted by liufengfeng (not verified) on July 2, 2011 - 5:45am.

Welcome to our Supra Shoes Online store.supra footwear outlet has became the most fashionable matterial all over the world.You wear supra shoes for sale ,you will be memmber of the fashion group.cheap supra footwear works great for most feet of human beings,though some people slander the supra footwear uk makes their feet slip further and the dicount supra footwear causes their heels pain.The supra shoes spring 2011 have a new enhancement of new supra trainers to help to cope with this problem - the heel collar of the supra trainers london was cut somehow lower.Supra tk Shoes are prepared to accept orders for supra trainers online now.Supra Shoes on sale had received by lots of supporters from the justin bieber supra shoes and concerns all over the world since fake supra footwear was published.Plenty of supra shoes store and supra shoes for kids are displayed on the supra men footwear online. They are waiting for you to look and feel the marrows of the branded popular Supra trainers . It' can be denied that Supra Trainers for women is the most famous model of Supra as supra shoes reviews have been creating and releasing all versions of supra footwear size ,the unique designs of supra footwear ns will stand out you from your mundane kicks buddies if you are wearing the supra sneakers .Certainly all of our supra skating footwear are no sales tax and free shipping.We looking forward your orders of supra shoes in uk .

mother Supra Skytop II,

Submitted by Supra TK Society (not verified) on July 2, 2011 - 12:12am.

mother
Supra Skytop II, brothers, is a supra society make you worry。as an excuse to stall the meet Supra TK Society, I Room, peeped through the photos my father , my mother ’s picture. the photo and the woman , smiling flower Supra Strapped II, as it is and I have a face exactly the same as me and my mother . I am glad , as I have a mother ’s face Supra Thunder Hightop, At least my father could not bear to hurt to me.
I would not rely on Supra Shoes for sale, and sometimes even I make a suggestion on what . In the body, I felt a feeling never experienced . may be that you care deeply about this young lady Supra Vaider Shoes, Miss supra supra tk tells the truth to be horrid to you Women’s Supra Shoes. supra society smiled, I hold back supra supra tk, Supra Cuttler
you finally come back 。and the third is the main force ambushes a group from the completion of an engineering battalion deployed To them Supra Indy NS, and three thousand troops, should be , while the attack alone Supra Strapped NS,there are four groups Longyuan completed

Discount sunglasses

Submitted by Discount sunglasses (not verified) on July 2, 2011 - 12:09am.

http://www.cheaphatsale.com

Submitted by Wholesale New Era Hats (not verified) on July 1, 2011 - 6:36pm.

Wholesale New Era Hats
Wholesale Fox Racing Hats

wholesale New Era MLB Hats
New York Yankees Hats
Houston Astros Hats
Atlanta Braves Hats
Boston Red Sox Hats
Colorado Rockies Hats
Baltimore Orioles Hats
Chicago Cubs Hats
Chicago White Sox Hats
Cincinnati Reds Hats
Cleveland Indians Hats
Detroit Tigers Hats
Florida Marlins Hats
Kansas City Royals Hats
Los Angeles Angels Hats
Milwaukee Brewers Hats
Minnesota Twins Hats
New York Mets Hats
Oakland Athletics Hats
Philadelphia Phillies Hats
Pittsburgh Pirates Hats
San Diego Padres Hats
San Francisco Gaints Hats
St.Louis Cardinals Hats
Tampa Bay Rays Hats
Texas Rangers Hats
Toronto BLue Jays Hats
Washington Nationals Hats
Seattle Mariners Hats
Arizona Diamondbacks Hats
wholesale New Era Jordan Hats
wholesale NBA hats
wholesale NFL hats
wholesale A&F hats
wholesale ED Hardy hats
Famous Start hats
wholesale Red Bull hats
wholesale Rockstar Energy hats
wholesale Monster Energy hats
wholesale Polo hats
The Hundreds Hats
2011 new Arrival hats
wholesale DC Shoes Hats

Wholesale New Era Hats
Wholesale Fox Racing Hats
wholesale New Era MLB Hats
New York Yankees Hats
Houston Astros Hats
Atlanta Braves Hats
Boston Red Sox Hats
Colorado Rockies Hats
Baltimore Orioles Hats
Chicago Cubs Hats
Chicago White Sox Hats
Cincinnati Reds Hats
Cleveland Indians Hats
Detroit Tigers Hats
Florida Marlins Hats
Kansas City Royals Hats
Los Angeles Angels Hats
Milwaukee Brewers Hats
Minnesota Twins Hats
New York Mets Hats
Oakland Athletics Hats
Philadelphia Phillies Hats
Pittsburgh Pirates Hats
San Diego Padres Hats
San Francisco Gaints Hats
St.Louis Cardinals Hats
Tampa Bay Rays Hats
Texas Rangers Hats
Toronto BLue Jays Hats
Washington Nationals Hats
Seattle Mariners Hats
Arizona Diamondbacks Hats
wholesale New Era Jordan Hats
wholesale NBA hats
wholesale NFL hats
wholesale A&F hats
wholesale ED Hardy hats
Famous Start hats
wholesale Red Bull hats
wholesale Rockstar Energy hats
wholesale Monster Energy hats
wholesale Polo hats
The Hundreds Hats
2011 new Arrival hats
wholesale DC Shoes Hats

ray ban sunglasses

Submitted by ray ban sunglasses (not verified) on July 1, 2011 - 5:31pm.

ray ban sunglasses oakley sunglasses best sunglasses Airness Calvin Klein Carrera Chanel Dolce & Gabbana Dsquared2 Emporio Armani Fa?onnable Fendi Giorgio Armani Hugo Boss Just Cavalli Oakley Persol Police Prada Ray Ban Tom Ford Tommy Hilfiger Versace Vuarnet

cheap sunglasses

Submitted by cheap sunglasses (not verified) on June 30, 2011 - 11:56pm.

I often buy the cheap sunglasses from a chinese
sunglasses wholesale store.It provides all kinds of designer sunglasses.

cheap oakley sunglasses

Submitted by cheap oakley sunglasses (not verified) on June 30, 2011 - 11:55pm.

How to select oakley sunglasses cheap one you like?

Come here,go to our online shop.It will be easy for you to get

discount oakley sunglasses you want.

Post new comment

Your name:

E-mail:

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Homepage:

Subject:

Comment: *

Allowed HTML tags:
Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Web of Change 2011

Testimonials

Justin Perkins “Web of Change was a phenomenal opportunity for me to enter the world of social media. I was able to make relationships with leading players in the field, access open handed teachers, and gain invaluable insight about how the internet can apply to my work in business and finance for social change. I have met some of my favorite people in the world.”