Celebrating Risk-Taking in Progressive Organizing

Matt Stempeck is the Communications Manager at the New Organizing Institute. He has experience helping a wide range of organizations use technology to create social change. Most recently, Matt served as New Media Director at Americans for Campaign Reform, a grassroots organization advocating for citizen-funded elections.

Real breakthroughs usually start with big gambles.

When an experiment doesn’t turn out as planned, though, it can lead to embarrassment. Fear of embarrassment can lead to long-term risk-averse behavior — but fundamental change doesn’t happen unless organizers bet big now and then.

So instead of hiding our failed experiments, we want to celebrate them. Going after big results can lead to huge advancements even in defeat… IF we’re honest about what we tried, why it didn’t work, and what we learned.

Will you nominate a big risk you saw this year as 2010's Most Valuable Experiment?

We know that organizers took big risks this year, and we want to celebrate the spirit of experimentation. There’s a lot to be learned from the innovations and gambles; we just need to share them.

Experimentation is practically a religion in the web startup and software development worlds. The mantras, be they ‘fail better’ or ‘fail faster,’ have helped produce countless technologies and services we rely on every day. Twitter itself was an offshoot of a failed podcast service called Odeo (remember all the hype behind podcasting??). Facebook takes pride in their fails as proof that the company is confronting real challenges. Jimmy Wales gave a TEDx Tampa presentation on his three rather massive failures prior to starting Wikipedia (over Skype, as he was apparently one of the manny Snowmageddon refugees stranded in DC last winter).

At least twenty-five startups have even published candid post-mortems detailing why and how they folded. Individually, these stories can be embarrassing. But collectively, their sharing helps others learn and combat the modern day Horatio Algers with their “22-year old founders getting rich, quickly!” magazine covers.

For examples of organizers willing to share what works and what doesn’t with their members and their peers, look to movement leaders like 1Sky and the Sunlight Foundation. Garth Moore, Michael Silberman, and Liz Butler of the 1Sky campaign against climate change publicly shared a mis-step this September, and even wrote up a helpful case study (part 1 and part 2) to share with the online advocacy community at Frogloop.

Because they shared their time and had the humility to report back, other groups considering a similar strategy of developing a custom community platform can avoid making the same mistakes. Their two-part report offers a useful template for others writing case studies of their own. Their format goes:

  • Our Story
  • Original vision and mission behind what we hoped to build
  • Our plan of action
  • What went wrong
  • Attempts to correct
  • Lessons learned (as you’ll notice, this is the longest and most detailed section)

In the same spirit, Noah Kunin at the Sunlight Foundation actually sent an e-mail blast to their members admitting the failure of one tool and online strategy this April:

One of the most important aspects of any campaign is to be unafraid to recognize that something is not working, and change direction accordingly. …

We launched the Public=Online website with the ability for users to create Groups which people could organize around, but, unfortunately, these tools simply aren’t working and are instead slowing the entire campaign down. So we’re going to do away with the Groups function for now.  This also means that we’re eliminating all the user accounts and event creation tools associated with those Groups. …

Our new system will focus on actions and projects and not additional online networks for you to manage.

This honesty, responsiveness, and willingness to share will help us move forward, as organizers working on individual campaigns and as a collective movement.

(On a side note, it sounds like a number of organizations are struggling with how to organize groups of members online).

Maybe you needed to persuade a legislator, and used a petition from his campaign volunteers as leverage. You didn’t get his vote, but you got media coverage, gained supporters, and developed bigger power and stronger strategies for the next round. Maybe you launched an online campaign that didn’t resonate with your audience, but gave you valuable information about their values and interests. Maybe you scrapped paid canvassing to run an all-volunteer program, and discovered that you needed to change your approach in the field to make that plan succeed.

This category recognizes the pioneers who struck out in a new direction, and showed the rest of us a path to take (or not take). We’re looking for strategies, gambles and tactics that didn’t work quite the way they were planned, but provided valuable lessons nonetheless.

Let’s acknowledge the people who put their chips on the table, and celebrate their attempts to flip conventional wisdom.

Whose bold risks inspired you in 2010? Nominate them for recognition as 2010′s Most Valuable Experiment. 

We’re presenting Most Valuable Organizing Awards in four categories: Most Valuable Organizer, Campaign, Tech and Experiment. The Top 3 in each category will be announced and voted on at National RootsCamp in Washington, DC, December 11-12. Even if you don’t have an experiment to nominate, you can participate by voting for your favorites.

Lastly, for more on leveraging failure for better future results, check out Lifehacker’s posts on the topic.


Add Your Comment

Louboutins Sales

Do things have the courage to the pay of the action new christian louboutin shoes, not the pay of the action louboutins sale, even if there is again good idea, we also only will stay the same christian louboutin ankle boots. So, when we are going to have to do something christian louboutin pumps, once you have the necessary preparations will act immediately christian louboutin sandals, otherwise, it is a good idea won't be reality. http://www.louboutinssales.com/

christian louboutin boots

Correctly understanding the value of yourself discount christian louboutins, is one of the important for successful factors sales louboutins. But in real life, we tend to be too low or too high to judge their own value christian louboutin mary jane pumps To correctly understand the value of yourself, will have an objective understanding christian louboutin pumps. Only the correct understanding oneself of value, we can realize their value. http://www.saleslouboutin.com/

marc jacobs eyeglasses is

marc jacobs eyeglasses is correctional eyesight or eye protection and make simple optical device. Composed by lens and frames. Vision correction use glasses have myopia discount marc jacobs sunglasses and farsightedness glasses, marc jacobs and astigmatism glasses four. Protect eyes with glasses have bond and basto protection lens, the degree of FengJing and fairy dean Laura cindylaura sunglasses, etc. marc jacobs sunglasses is both eye protection tools, it is a kind of hairdressing decorations.

manolo blahnik

For people looking for something more classic in women's shoes this season, rely on our Manolo Blahnik Sale! These classic Manolo Blahnik Shoes are distinguished with a practical and sexy flat-sole design that men will admire. Manolo Blahnik is a world famous brand making adorable women shoes. Why not purchase one pair of Manolo Shoes right now?

Pencil True Religion Outlet

Pencil True Religion Outlet is fit for girls who have thin leg.Generally speaking,we see the magazine models,the leg is very thin.Consequently,if you do not have thin leg True Religion Canada,not to try it.Cuffless cheap True Religion jeans is appropriate for girls who have thick thigh,more deep color,more betetr,do not choose light colorTrue Religion Canada Outlet.Flared True Religion jeans on sale suits girls who have thick shank,the loose leg mouth design can shut out your crucal meat.Extravagant leg discount True Religion jeans is fit for tall girls who have strong leg True Religion Jeans Cheap,it not only can shut out your meat,but also make you have a feeling of European and American street corner True Religion Jeans Canada wind.


You might be confused of choosing what kinds of favorite among all the charming jewelries. Then come to our Tiffany and co outlet! We designed a clear catalogue and you can see easily of all the Tiffany Jewelry. It’s a good and convenient way to shop on Tiffany Jewelry Outlet online. Now purchase the reliable Tiffany On Sale in time.

red bottom shoes

If you are looking for a pair of elegant and modern women shoes, the Red Bottom Heels will undoubtedly be the first option. Of all the hot looks in women's shoes for 2011, the most shimmering would undoubtedly be the gold and silver Red Sole Shoes! Exquisite and tasteful styles are brought by Red Bottom Shoes. We feel honor if you shop at our Louis Vuitton Outlet.


Cepia the wire complete series sees lost dvds films as monk season new way nip tuck dvds to expand ncis dvds its toy one tree hill dvd season line that profiler dvds has true blood dvds sold prison break dvds million pushing daisies dvds hamsters mac makeup wholesale more than mac cosmetics countries mac makeup since two and a half men dvds bowing seinfeld dvds in 2009. Bringing sopranos seasons Pets to star trek dvds life through spooks series magic of scrubs dvds movies is ansex and the city dvds exciting new six feet under dvds chapter in south park dvds Zhu-niverse supernatural dvds evolution, said stargate atlantis dvds Russ Hornsby, smallville dvds of weeds dvds Cepia. Creating wholesale mac products movies is discount mac makeup an exciting mac cosmetics wholesale new experience mac makeup products ZhuZhu wholesale mac cosmetics Pets will and grace seasons and wholesale mac Cepia and wholesale mac cosmetics suppliers with these wholesale mac makeup films we wholesale mac makeup products have another wholesale mac products way for our stargate sg 1 dvd brand to the 4400 dvds come alive king of queens seasons for the the hills dvds fans. Louis-based the office dvds Cepia ZhuZhu the unit dvds Pets line the oc dvds has xena dvds also the simpsons dvds spun off the shield dvd Kung Zhu the oz dvds Princess, ZhuZhu the tribe dvds Babies and the west wing dvds ZhuZhu the files dvds Puppieshttp://tvshowcity.wordpress.com and http://tvshowcity.blogspot.com/ Babies.


hermes salegap have specific is through what they have to offer in B remove the chest to take enough long time to, hermes handbags out of your hand than you of shoulder intention
Higher, belong to all the channel of the machine tools. cheap hermes can can be in your hips or the waist and place, there are countless outside pockets organization slot. Chic hermes leather beltD like a gentle the unique style of moon tramp bag, is undoubtedly a useful and necessary diaper bag and the Exceptional hermes bags (A) some luxury handbags means artist.Good taste, the pursuit of individual character of fashion. Whether simple or ornate, Whether conservative or avant-garde, cheap hermescan be used to decorate it.

You might be confused of

You might be confused of choosing what kinds of favorite among all the charming jewelries. Then come to our Tiffany and co outlet! We designed a clear catalogue and you can see easily of all the Tiffany Jewelry. It’s a good and convenient way to shop on Tiffany Jewelry Outlet online. Now purchase the reliable Tiffany On Sale in time.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Presenting & Title Sponsors

Advomatic Agentic SAP


Biro Creative Communicopia Sam Dorman Consulting EchoDitto Englin Consulting

Movement Builders

Salsa Labs Care2 Mobile Commons


Free Range Studios